Clinique Almost Lipstick — Black HoneySheer lipstick

THE COMMUNITY TAKE

Clinique Almost Lipstick — Black Honey review

A distinctive sheer color, with mixed comfort and short wear.

3.2 / 5

Weighted review score33 eligible reviews · 2 source websites

Developing review coverage

33 eligible reviews across 2 websites. The largest source supplies 76% of these reviews. What this means

33 accounts examined · 33 consumer accounts
Provisional score · 33 ratings estimated from text

People liked

  • Sheer color and easy application [12] [13]

Worth knowing

  • Dryness or patchiness [2] [15]
  • Frequent reapplication [21]
The fuller pictureSummary & product version

Users praise the color and easy sheen. Others describe dryness, patchiness or frequent reapplication. This sample is concentrated in two Reddit discussions, not a representative survey.

Product version. Almost Lipstick in Black Honey only; excludes Pink/Nude Honey, lip gloss, oil and Diamond editions. Experiences name Black Honey; individual batches are unverified.

These are reported experiences, not clinical findings. Themes describe the full sample; score filters do not rewrite the summary.

SEVERAL PLACES. ONE PICTURE.

Where this brief comes from

33 accounts · 2 websites

Share of accounts examined, including exclusions. Score influence is weighted separately. Tap a source to read an attributed review. Known syndicated reviews are grouped with their original publisher.

WHERE TO BUY

Shopping options

Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission from links marked “Paid link”, at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our scores.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Check the selected version, shade, size and delivery at the store. Prices, stock and sellers can change.

Read the 33 review summaries33 consumer accounts · source links included

Sources include Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction, Reddit · r/Makeup, Temptalia · reader review, Temptalia · reader comment.

English paraphrases with original sources. Source ratings and text estimates are labeled. Unknown commercial ties do not prove independence.

1. jfal93

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

4Text estimate / 5

Enjoyed the color and moisture.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: jfal93; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

2. pushpop0201

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Liked color; disliked waxiness and emphasized dryness.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 42/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 70/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: pushpop0201; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

3. yummy_food

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Found it clung to dry patches.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 33/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 55/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: yummy_food; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

4. PetiteAsianWoman

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Preferred cheaper balms for their dry lips.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 33/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 55/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: PetiteAsianWoman; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

5. Wonderful-Cow9297

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

5Text estimate / 5

Loved the shade when applied lightly.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 27/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 45/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Wonderful-Cow9297; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

6. SneakyVonSneakyPants

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

3Text estimate / 5

Rarely reached for its drying, unremarkable color.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 39/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: SneakyVonSneakyPants; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

7. Giminykrikits

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Disliked the color on pale, cool-toned skin.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Giminykrikits; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

8. GenuineClamhat

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Found the color muddy.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 24/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 40/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: GenuineClamhat; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

9. fakesaucisse

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Was disappointed by the muddy color.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 24/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 40/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: fakesaucisse; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

10. Global_Ant_9380

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

5Text estimate / 5

Loved the color on deep, warm-toned skin.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 33/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 55/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Global_Ant_9380; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

11. Island_Slut69

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

5Text estimate / 5

Loved the color on medium olive skin.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Island_Slut69; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

12. Extension-Aside-6553

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

5Text estimate / 5

Loved color and convenience over Aquaphor.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 42/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 70/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Extension-Aside-6553; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

13. BackgroundPin8471

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

5Text estimate / 5

Liked its light, glossy, nonsticky feel.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: BackgroundPin8471; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

14. my_metrocard

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

3Text estimate / 5

Needed primer to prevent pigment settling.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: my_metrocard; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

15. thehonestbreadloaf

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

1Text estimate / 5

Regretted buying it: patchiness, dryness and fading.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as stated
Experimental evidence weight 75/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 75/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Reports buying it during a sale; not externally verified.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: thehonestbreadloaf; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

16. JuJusPetals

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Rarely chose it over a cheaper alternative.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: JuJusPetals; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

17. floralscentedbreeze

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Needed balm underneath to counter dryness.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as stated
Experimental evidence weight 65/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Reports buying it during a sale; not externally verified.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: floralscentedbreeze; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

18. eightyfiveMRtwo

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

4Text estimate / 5

Liked slip and moisture; still used balm underneath.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 39/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: eightyfiveMRtwo; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

19. mrs-sir-walter-scott

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Found it drying with underwhelming color.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: mrs-sir-walter-scott; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

20. persephone151

Reddit · r/MakeupAddiction · May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

4Text estimate / 5

Loved carrying it, despite limited hydration.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Firsthand reply in explicit Almost Lipstick Black Honey discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: persephone151; May 2025 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

21. Wise_Television1359

Reddit · r/Makeup · June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

3Text estimate / 5

Loved the color but reapplied about every 90 minutes.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 42/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 70/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Wise_Television1359; June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

22. TryTwiceAsHard

Reddit · r/Makeup · June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

1Text estimate / 5

Stopped using it because of uncomfortable dryness.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: TryTwiceAsHard; June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

23. lilburblue

Reddit · r/Makeup · June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

2Text estimate / 5

Found the formula drying.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 24/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 40/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: lilburblue; June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

24. Few_Resource_6783

Reddit · r/Makeup · June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

1Text estimate / 5

Found dryness even over moisturizing balm.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 39/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. Specific personal observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Few_Resource_6783; June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

25. hotheadnchickn

Reddit · r/Makeup · June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable

5Text estimate / 5

Returned after finding alternatives insufficiently similar.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. Brief firsthand opinion.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual funding disclosure found; independence is not established.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick discussion; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: hotheadnchickn; June 2026 discussion; exact comment date unavailable. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

26. Elisaveta

Temptalia · reader review · 3 years ago

2Text estimate / 5

Liked buildability, but found flaking emphasized, little hydration and poor value; would not repurchase.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknownSkin: Combination
Experimental evidence weight 48/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 80/100. Detailed first-person wear, comfort and value observations.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No personal incentive disclosure was visible. Host affiliate links do not establish this reader’s commercial relationship.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick account. Historical batch and equivalence to the current formulation are unverified; not Pink Honey, gloss, oil or Chubby Stick.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Elisaveta; 3 years ago; individual review in the linked page. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

27. Lily Kelley

Temptalia · reader comment · 2017-10-16

5Text estimate / 5

Has worn it for years and enjoys the sheer, hydrating feel.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknownUse: Years
Experimental evidence weight 33/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 55/100. Firsthand longevity and sensory impressions; short historical account.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No personal incentive disclosure was visible. Host affiliate links do not establish this reader’s commercial relationship.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick account. Historical batch and equivalence to the current formulation are unverified; not Pink Honey, gloss, oil or Chubby Stick.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Lily Kelley; 2017-10-16; individual review in the linked page. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

28. Nancy T

Temptalia · reader comment · 2017-10-16

5Text estimate / 5

Still considers Black Honey a favorite for an understated lip look.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknownSkin: Combination
Experimental evidence weight 27/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 45/100. Personal preference is clear but wear details are limited.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No personal incentive disclosure was visible. Host affiliate links do not establish this reader’s commercial relationship.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick account. Historical batch and equivalence to the current formulation are unverified; not Pink Honey, gloss, oil or Chubby Stick.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Nancy T; 2017-10-16; individual review in the linked page. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

29. Maria

Temptalia · reader comment · 2017-10-16

5Text estimate / 5

A longstanding favorite, although she found a less expensive tinted-balm alternative.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 33/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 55/100. Personal preference and a comparative value observation.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No personal incentive disclosure was visible. Host affiliate links do not establish this reader’s commercial relationship.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick account. Historical batch and equivalence to the current formulation are unverified; not Pink Honey, gloss, oil or Chubby Stick.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Maria; 2017-10-16; individual review in the linked page. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

30. Emily

Temptalia · reader comment · 2017-10-17

5Text estimate / 5

Continues wearing it and has bought it more than once.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as stated
Experimental evidence weight 55/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 55/100. Clear firsthand repeat use, with limited performance detail.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Explicitly describes repeat purchases.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick account. Historical batch and equivalence to the current formulation are unverified; not Pink Honey, gloss, oil or Chubby Stick.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Emily; 2017-10-17; individual review in the linked page. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

31. Rachel R.

Temptalia · reader comment · 2017-10-16

3Text estimate / 5

Found the formula acceptable, but the sheer rust color unremarkable on her lips.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknownSkin: Normal-to-oily
Experimental evidence weight 42/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 70/100. Two comments from one account describe ownership and balanced wear impressions.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No personal incentive disclosure was visible. Host affiliate links do not establish this reader’s commercial relationship.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick account. Historical batch and equivalence to the current formulation are unverified; not Pink Honey, gloss, oil or Chubby Stick.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Rachel R.; 2017-10-16; individual review in the linked page. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

32. Jane

Temptalia · reader comment · 2017-10-16

2Text estimate / 5

Disliked the brown tone it took on her lips.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Specific personal shade mismatch; no broader suitability claim is inferred.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No personal incentive disclosure was visible. Host affiliate links do not establish this reader’s commercial relationship.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick account. Historical batch and equivalence to the current formulation are unverified; not Pink Honey, gloss, oil or Chubby Stick.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Jane; 2017-10-16; individual review in the linked page. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

33. Jen

Temptalia · reader comment · 2017-10-17

5Text estimate / 5

Enjoyed the color after buying it, although preferred the separate Chubby Stick version.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as statedUse: One to two months since purchase
Experimental evidence weight 60/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Own purchase and explicit comparison; the other product is not scored here.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Explicitly says she bought Black Honey.

Text estimate: 1 strongly negative; 2 negative; 3 mixed; 4 positive; 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. Explicit Black Honey Almost Lipstick account. Historical batch and equivalence to the current formulation are unverified; not Pink Honey, gloss, oil or Chubby Stick.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Jen; 2017-10-17; individual review in the linked page. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review
How the score worksReview weights, filters & source mix

More detailed experience carries more weight. Known sponsorship, gifts, affiliate ties and incentives reduce it. Unknown relationships stay labeled as unknown.

Weight = documentation quality × commercial factor. These are experimental editorial choices, not a probability that a review is true.

Unknown relationships remain included. Verified purchase does not mean incentive-free.

Adjust commercial weights

Source influence

reddit.com25 reviews
73%
temptalia.com8 reviews
27%
Every contribution to the score
ReviewerRatingWeightContribution
jfal934/50.301.20
pushpop02012/50.420.84
yummy_food2/50.330.66
PetiteAsianWoman2/50.330.66
Wonderful-Cow92975/50.271.35
SneakyVonSneakyPants3/50.391.17
Giminykrikits2/50.300.60
GenuineClamhat2/50.240.48
fakesaucisse2/50.240.48
Global_Ant_93805/50.331.65
Island_Slut695/50.301.50
Extension-Aside-65535/50.422.10
BackgroundPin84715/50.361.80
my_metrocard3/50.361.08
thehonestbreadloaf1/50.750.75
JuJusPetals2/50.300.60
floralscentedbreeze2/50.651.30
eightyfiveMRtwo4/50.391.56
mrs-sir-walter-scott2/50.360.72
persephone1514/50.361.44
Wise_Television13593/50.421.26
TryTwiceAsHard1/50.360.36
lilburblue2/50.240.48
Few_Resource_67831/50.390.39
hotheadnchickn5/50.301.50
Elisaveta2/50.480.96
Lily Kelley5/50.331.65
Nancy T5/50.271.35
Maria5/50.331.65
Emily5/50.552.75
Rachel R.3/50.421.26
Jane2/50.360.72
Jen5/50.603.00

Weighted total 39.27 ÷ total weight 12.45 = 3.2 / 5

33 of 33 included scores are estimated from text. At least 10 eligible reviews are required.

A large source can dominate. This accessible-page sample is not representative of all buyers. Full methodology

Research notesIdentity, store ratings & limitations

All recorded accounts come from two Reddit discussions. User identity, purchase and formula batch are not independently verified.

Check the official product page

Known repeat authors are consolidated. Identities and batches cannot always be verified across platforms. Public review ordering and source availability can bias the sample.

Selected for accessible product-specific consumer evidence; not a current popularity ranking. Selection source

AI-assisted research · Snapshot: 2026-11-16. This is a synthesis of published accounts, not our own product test. All coverage counts