Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Washable MascaraMascara

THE COMMUNITY TAKE

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara review

Length and separation win fans; clumps and removal disappoint some.

4.5 / 5

Weighted review score28 eligible reviews · 6 source websites

Developing review coverage

28 eligible reviews across 6 websites. The largest source supplies 68% of these reviews. What this means

28 accounts examined · 24 consumer accounts
Provisional score · 4 ratings estimated from text

People liked

Worth knowing

The fuller pictureSummary & product version

The read sample highlights length, separation and repeat purchases, alongside application and removal complaints. Most iHerb reviews were rewarded; Ulta adds critical experiences. These reports do not establish frequency or performance for every washable shade.

Product version. Washable Sky High, not Waterproof. iHerb sample is 801 Very Black; Ulta pools washable shades. Shade and batch are unverified unless explicitly stated. Photo shows Blackest Black washable packaging.

These are reported experiences, not clinical findings. Themes describe the full sample; score filters do not rewrite the summary.

SEVERAL PLACES. ONE PICTURE.

Where this brief comes from

28 accounts · 6 websites

Share of accounts examined, including exclusions. Score influence is weighted separately. Tap a source to read an attributed review. Known syndicated reviews are grouped with their original publisher.

WHERE TO BUY

Shopping options

Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission from links marked “Paid link”, at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our scores.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Check the selected version, shade, size and delivery at the store. Prices, stock and sellers can change.

Read the 28 review summaries24 consumer accounts · source links included

Sources include iHerb, Ulta, Target · customer reviews, reviewed.com · hands-on editorial, womanandhome.com · hands-on editorial, glamourmagazine.co.uk · hands-on editorial.

English paraphrases with original sources. Source ratings and text estimates are labeled. Unknown commercial ties do not prove independence.

1. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2025-04-10

5Source rating / 5

Likes the length, volume and easy application.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 21/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 30/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 020093d5-52ce-4078-977f-e9b1e6f6ee06 · Apr 10, 2025. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

2. Shani

iHerb · 2025-04-18

5Source rating / 5

Very black color separates and lengthens lashes well.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 32/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 45/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 12a1aba6-e6df-4665-8849-fc3a5ca7bf1c · Apr 18, 2025. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

3. 40plus-care

iHerb · 2024-03-01

5Source rating / 5

Silicone brush lengthens lashes without clumps or sticking.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 35/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 30cdb357-f6db-422d-a925-c31ea42de63e · Mar 1, 2024. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

4. iHerbCustomer

iHerb · 2025-06-19

5Source rating / 5

Separates and lengthens without clumps; removes easily with warm water.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 35/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review a30b11e8-2338-4cc0-b745-c02e8e41e92d · Jun 19, 2025. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

5. iHerbCustomer

iHerb · 2025-11-27

5Source rating / 5

Enjoys easy application and reports it stayed on during swimming.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 24/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 35/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review f015e720-374d-43c1-84cb-e9d73777aea3 · Nov 27, 2025. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

6. MayaP

iHerb · 2026-09-13

5Source rating / 5

Keeps returning for natural length, volume and all-day wear without clumps.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 45/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. First-person use with specific performance and routine or skin context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review b1b8a067-cb1b-4227-beca-5f39678760b6 · Sep 13, 2026. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

7. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2025-05-04

5Source rating / 5

Favorite mascara; removes easily with face wash or cleansing oil.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 35/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 6e7840e0-ed5c-4ac3-aeb7-d57818b0ca78 · May 4, 2025. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

8. Iris55andOver

iHerb · 2025-03-19

5Source rating / 5

After several days, finds buildable volume, long wear and easy removal.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 42/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. First-person use with specific performance and routine or skin context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 37dbd33b-1529-4fe7-9cd0-ebb93d114f3e · Mar 19, 2025. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

9. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2025-01-01

5Source rating / 5

Repeat purchase for near-daily use; likes dark color and lash lift.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 32/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 45/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 5205357f-4fbe-4926-bce7-309792e680f7 · Jan 1, 2025. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

10. Linoylevi1

iHerb · 2023-10-29

5Source rating / 5

Likes the brush, soft-looking curl and usable tube size.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 24/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 35/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 0f3c6ec7-6fb5-4521-9593-66304d0e21a0 · Oct 29, 2023. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

11. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2026-10-24

5Source rating / 5

Repurchases for dark, dramatic lashes and easy removal.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 28/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 40/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 3d94fbdc-65fc-4da9-8af3-8ee00258bc84 · Oct 24, 2026. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

12. iHerbCustomer

iHerb · 2024-08-23

5Source rating / 5

Favorite affordable mascara for volume and a comfortable brush.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 24/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 35/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review fe963631-fe26-47d3-b239-e05df9bbbba5 · Aug 23, 2024. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

13. Revi

iHerb · 2024-03-05

5Source rating / 5

Finds the strong color and lasting texture easy to use.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 21/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 30/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 4167d740-b6e3-4821-ae49-0c6cea04a1b8 · Mar 5, 2024. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

14. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2024-02-11

5Source rating / 5

One or two coats give separated, fuller lashes; plans to repurchase.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 42/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. First-person use with specific performance and routine or skin context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 041b8091-c572-4790-adcb-845736b29061 · Feb 11, 2024. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

15. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2026-08-07

5Source rating / 5

Likes length and volume without daytime flaking; plans another purchase.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 35/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review e487cc8e-c7d6-4ddd-8a9e-a3882823a54c · Aug 7, 2026. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

16. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2026-04-08

5Source rating / 5

Frequently uses it for defined lashes and easy application.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 24/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 35/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 859d9ed8-2331-4687-93e9-1446e87f1115 · Apr 8, 2026. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

17. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2026-02-03

5Source rating / 5

Finds the brush comfortable, with lengthening and long wear without smudging.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 32/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 45/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review a10cfb9f-f385-40f6-a644-0820e24692dc · Feb 3, 2026. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

18. Lior

iHerb · 2026-01-08

5Source rating / 5

Repeat buyer likes length; finds removal somewhat difficult.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 35/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review a86cd994-659d-4cce-a653-9b01c776fa72 · Jan 8, 2026. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

19. לקוח/ת iHerb

iHerb · 2025-01-03

5Source rating / 5

Likes the mascara after learning to handle its brush.

Consumer reviewReview incentiveVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 21/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 30/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.70. iHerb marks this review as rewarded (hasRewarded: true).

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. iHerb 801 Very Black, 7.2 ml listing; official Maybelline page identifies 801 as washable. Batch unverified. Water-resistance anecdotes are not waterproof-formula verification.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: iHerb review 35bca666-8df1-4ea7-b464-47c94325481a · Jan 3, 2025. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

20. Annìe

Ulta · 7 days ago

5Source rating / 5

Loves the length, lack of smudging and easy water removal.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No commercial disclosure found in the text read; independence is unknown.

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. Posted on the washable Sky High listing; shade and batch unspecified. Retailer reviews may be pooled; not independently confirmed from packaging.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Annìe · 7 days ago · Excellent mascara. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

21. A

Ulta · 9 days ago

1Source rating / 5

Reports clumps, flakes, eye discomfort and difficult removal.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No commercial disclosure found in the text read; independence is unknown.

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. Posted on the washable Sky High listing; shade and batch unspecified. Retailer reviews may be pooled; not independently confirmed from packaging.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: A · 9 days ago · Worst mascara ever!. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

22. Steph

Ulta · 9 days ago

1Source rating / 5

Overloaded brush leaves wet, short-looking lashes without desired volume.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person product experience; limited wear duration or routine context.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No commercial disclosure found in the text read; independence is unknown.

Numeric star rating displayed in the original source. Posted on the washable Sky High listing; shade and batch unspecified. Retailer reviews may be pooled; not independently confirmed from packaging.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Steph · 9 days ago · Not a good buy. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

23. Missy13

Target · customer reviews · 2026-11-06

3Source rating / 5

Little visible plum or volume, but no smudging or flaking.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as statedSkin: Dry
Experimental evidence weight 70/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 70/100. Firsthand product use; detail varies. Public identity and authenticity are not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Explicitly purchased Plum Twilight; other relationships unverified.

Published source stars, retained even when text sentiment differs. Explicit Plum Twilight shade; Target places this shade under Washable. Color result is shade-specific.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Missy13, 6 November 2026, title about Plum Twilight color. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

24. Jamie

Target · customer reviews · 2026-10-22

5Source rating / 5

Liked the brown shade.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknownVerified purchase in sourceSkin: Combination
Experimental evidence weight 15/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 25/100. Firsthand product use; detail varies. Public identity and authenticity are not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No individual commercial disclosure visible; absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Published source stars, retained even when text sentiment differs. Review explicitly says Brown. Washable inferred from Target’s sole brown option, 804 True Brown; exact SKU and batch unverified. Color-specific account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Jamie, 22 October 2026, Verified purchase, Brown color comment. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

25. Brigitt Earley

reviewed.com · hands-on editorial · 2021-03-11

3Text estimate / 5

Lengthened lashes, but clumping kept it from replacing her favorite.

Creator / editorial reviewAffiliate link
Experimental evidence weight 60/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 80/100. Named author provides a firsthand test with personal context; editorial affiliation is retained separately.

Commercial factor: 0.75. Article explicitly discloses commissions on purchases through links.

Editorial sentiment estimate: 1 strongly negative, 2 negative, 3 mixed, 4 positive, 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. No original star score used. Author explicitly tested Washable, not Waterproof; historical batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Brigitt Earley firsthand testing section, 2021-03-11. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

26. Lucy Abbersteen

womanandhome.com · hands-on editorial · 2022-02-07

5Text estimate / 5

Liked length and wear; removal took effort; repeatedly repurchased.

Creator / editorial reviewAffiliate link
Experimental evidence weight 60/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 80/100. Named author provides a firsthand test with personal context; editorial affiliation is retained separately.

Commercial factor: 0.75. Article explicitly discloses affiliate commissions.

Editorial sentiment estimate: 1 strongly negative, 2 negative, 3 mixed, 4 positive, 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. No original star score used. Original black Washable test; historical batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Lucy Abbersteen firsthand testing section, 2022-02-07. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

27. Georgia Brown

glamourmagazine.co.uk · hands-on editorial · 2025-10-07

5Text estimate / 5

Liked clean, defined lashes without flakes.

Creator / editorial reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 42/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 70/100. Named author provides a firsthand test with personal context; editorial affiliation is retained separately.

Commercial factor: 0.60. Commerce editorial includes tracked retailer links; precise compensation and product provision not visible.

Editorial sentiment estimate: 1 strongly negative, 2 negative, 3 mixed, 4 positive, 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. No original star score used. Original pink-tube test, discussed separately from Waterproof and Cosmic Black; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Georgia Brown firsthand testing section, 2025-10-07. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

28. Elle Turner

glamourmagazine.co.uk · hands-on editorial · 2025-10-07

5Text estimate / 5

One coat defined lashes naturally; became an office staple.

Creator / editorial reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 42/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 70/100. Named author provides a firsthand test with personal context; editorial affiliation is retained separately.

Commercial factor: 0.60. Commerce editorial includes tracked retailer links; precise compensation and product provision not visible.

Editorial sentiment estimate: 1 strongly negative, 2 negative, 3 mixed, 4 positive, 5 enthusiastic or repurchased. No original star score used. Original pink-tube test, discussed separately from Waterproof and Cosmic Black; batch unverified.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Elle Turner firsthand testing section, 2025-10-07. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review
How the score worksReview weights, filters & source mix

More detailed experience carries more weight. Known sponsorship, gifts, affiliate ties and incentives reduce it. Unknown relationships stay labeled as unknown.

Weight = documentation quality × commercial factor. These are experimental editorial choices, not a probability that a review is true.

Unknown relationships remain included. Verified purchase does not mean incentive-free.

Adjust commercial weights

Source influence

iherb.com19 reviews
61%
ulta.com3 reviews
9%
target.com2 reviews
9%
glamourmagazine.co.uk2 reviews
9%
reviewed.com1 review
6%
womanandhome.com1 review
6%
Every contribution to the score
ReviewerRatingWeightContribution
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.211.05
Shani5/50.321.57
40plus-care5/50.351.75
iHerbCustomer5/50.351.75
iHerbCustomer5/50.241.22
MayaP5/50.452.27
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.351.75
Iris55andOver5/50.422.10
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.321.57
Linoylevi15/50.241.22
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.281.40
iHerbCustomer5/50.241.22
Revi5/50.211.05
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.422.10
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.351.75
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.241.22
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.321.57
Lior5/50.351.75
לקוח/ת iHerb5/50.211.05
Annìe5/50.301.50
A1/50.300.30
Steph1/50.300.30
Missy133/50.702.10
Jamie5/50.150.75
Brigitt Earley3/50.601.80
Lucy Abbersteen5/50.603.00
Georgia Brown5/50.422.10
Elle Turner5/50.422.10

Weighted total 43.35 ÷ total weight 9.67 = 4.5 / 5

4 of 28 included scores are estimated from text. At least 10 eligible reviews are required.

A large source can dominate. This accessible-page sample is not representative of all buyers. Full methodology

Research notesIdentity, store ratings & limitations

Washable Sky High, not Waterproof. iHerb sample is 801 Very Black; Ulta pools washable shades. Shade and batch are unverified unless explicitly stated. Photo shows Blackest Black washable packaging.

Check the official product page

Known repeat authors are consolidated. Identities and batches cannot always be verified across platforms. Public review ordering and source availability can bias the sample.

Expanded makeup collection: selected for accessible product-specific consumer reviews, not a current popularity ranking. Selection source

A SEPARATE VIEW

What do the stores show?

These are platform-wide ratings observed during research. They are not our weighted score, and the full review collections behind them have not been read.

iHerb

Native listing total, separate from the individually read sample. Incentivized reviews are included by the platform.

4.6 / 54,796 platform ratings

AI-assisted research · Snapshot: 2026-11-16. This is a synthesis of published accounts, not our own product test. All coverage counts