NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid EyelinerEyeliner

THE COMMUNITY TAKE

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner review

Precision and dark pigment win some users over, but the recent sample has repeated complaints about leaking and smudging.

3.1 / 5

Weighted review score26 eligible reviews · 3 source websites

Developing review coverage

26 eligible reviews across 3 websites. The largest source supplies 62% of these reviews. What this means

28 accounts examined · 28 consumer accounts
Provisional score · 0 ratings estimated from text

People liked

  • Easy control and precise application [2] [14]
  • Some users get lasting, transfer-free lines [2] [9]

Worth knowing

  • Repeated reports of leaking pens [7] [12]
  • Smudging and faint lighter shades [3] [6]
The fuller pictureSummary & product version

Precision and dark pigment win some users over, but the recent sample has repeated complaints about leaking and smudging. Lighter brown shades receive different pigment feedback from black; these should not be treated as identical color results. Additional brand-page accounts reinforce both precise application and recurring leaks; syndicated Influenster reviews count as one origin.

Product version. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

More positives

  • Not enough specific evidence in this sample.

More trade-offs

  • Leaking pens recur among longtime users [22] [23]

These are reported experiences, not clinical findings. Themes describe the full sample; score filters do not rewrite the summary.

SEVERAL PLACES. ONE PICTURE.

Where this brief comes from

28 accounts · 4 websites

Share of accounts examined, including exclusions. Score influence is weighted separately. Tap a source to read an attributed review. Known syndicated reviews are grouped with their original publisher.

WHERE TO BUY

Shopping options

Check the selected version, shade, size and delivery at the store. Prices, stock and sellers can change.

Read the 28 review summaries28 consumer accounts · source links included

Sources include Ulta, iHerb, NYX.

English paraphrases with original sources. Source ratings and text estimates are labeled. Unknown commercial ties do not prove independence.

1. Kathy

Ulta · 2026-11-09

1Source rating / 5

Reports only a few hours of wear.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 18/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 30/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 590009251 · Kathy · I wouldn't buy again. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

2. Kait

Ulta · 2026-10-29

5Source rating / 5

After a week, finds the liner easy to control, pigmented and resistant to lid transfer.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 39/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 589544284 · Kait · Surprisingly easy to apply & no lid transfer!. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

3. Stacy

Ulta · 2026-10-28

3Source rating / 5

Selected a brown shade that appeared much lighter than expected.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 589272663 · Stacy · Ok. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

4. Anne

Ulta · 2026-10-27

1Source rating / 5

For dotting between lashes, finds it too thick to smudge and prone to flaking.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 39/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 589231865 · Anne · Thick and hard to apply. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

5. Brit

Ulta · 2026-10-23

1Source rating / 5

Finds the color too faint.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 18/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 30/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 589005598 · Brit · Terrible product. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

6. quinn

Ulta · 2026-10-23

1Source rating / 5

Reports smudging and messy wear throughout the day.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 39/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 589004736 · quinn · smudges throughout the day. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

7. Bee

Ulta · 2026-10-09

1Source rating / 5

Longtime user reports leaking and more frequent smudging in recent purchases.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 39/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 588306756 · Bee · Changed Formula?. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

8. xc

Ulta · 2026-10-08

1Source rating / 5

Needs several layers to approach the advertised color.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 588250556 · xc · Mid(night) rise. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

9. Deborah

Ulta · 2026-10-06

5Source rating / 5

Reports wear without smudging until removal.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 18/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 30/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 588206964 · Deborah · Good product. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

10. Moo

Ulta · 2026-10-05

3Source rating / 5

Finds Graham Cracker poorly pigmented and unlike the pictured shade.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 588166016 · Moo · Not the best. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

11. Texas Girly

Ulta · 2026-09-29

2Source rating / 5

Reports poor wear on combination-oily skin despite setting spray.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 587999609 · Texas Girly · Lasted about 2-ish hours on.. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

12. Trina

Ulta · 2026-09-21

1Source rating / 5

Recent repurchase runs into the eyes despite blotting first.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as stated
Experimental evidence weight 50/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Reviewer explicitly describes buying or paying for the product in their account; not externally verified and does not exclude undisclosed incentives.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 587680732 · Trina · Won't use anymore. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

13. Soska

Ulta · 2026-09-19

1Source rating / 5

Reports upper-lid transfer and lingering pigment during removal.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 587531834 · Soska · Waste of money. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

14. Adeline

Ulta · 2026-09-17

2Source rating / 5

Likes precision and black pigment, but repeatedly experiences leaks halfway through a pen.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as stated
Experimental evidence weight 65/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 65/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Reviewer explicitly describes buying or paying for the product in their account; not externally verified and does not exclude undisclosed incentives.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 587335915 · Adeline · Fantastic, but only briefly.... Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

15. LBinCLE

Ulta · 2026-09-17

5Source rating / 5

Likes a lighter brown for a soft wing on hooded eyes.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 587334038 · LBinCLE · Good for soft, winged edges. Waterproof.. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

16. Jaythan

Ulta · 2026-09-14

5Source rating / 5

Daily wearer likes its affordability, ease and dark color.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 30/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 50/100. First-person experience. More context and specific use details receive more documentation weight; account identity is not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No gift or payment statement or verified-purchase badge in the returned individual record. Absence of disclosure does not establish independence.

Numeric star rating attached to this exact native review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: 587156069 · Jaythan · My Gothic Go To. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

17. Rosie

iHerb · 2026-03-29

—No numeric rating

Likes Dark Chocolate’s smooth color but eyeshadow disrupts the line.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknownVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 27/100

Excluded from score: Unscored qualitative account; retained for context without inventing stars.

Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 45/100. Product-specific first-person account; public identity and batch not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. Page labels verified purchase. Individual reward status not exposed; iHerb operates a review-rewards program, so purchase status does not establish independence.

Qualitative evidence only: no reliable numeric star rating exposed. Not converted into a star score. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Rosie · 2026-03-29 · Likes Dark Chocolate’s smooth color but eyeshadow disrupts the li. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

18. IHerbmacaofan

iHerb · 2026-10-08

—No numeric rating

Likes the precise tip and reports no smudging.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknownVerified purchase in source
Experimental evidence weight 27/100

Excluded from score: Unscored qualitative account; retained for context without inventing stars.

Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 45/100. Product-specific first-person account; public identity and batch not independently verified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. Page labels verified purchase. Individual reward status not exposed; iHerb operates a review-rewards program, so purchase status does not establish independence.

Qualitative evidence only: no reliable numeric star rating exposed. Not converted into a star score. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: IHerbmacaofan · 2026-10-08 · Likes the precise tip and reports no smudging.. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

19. KKWW

NYX · 5 days ago

5Source rating / 5

Black liner applies easily and stays through a busy workday.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No review-specific gift or payment statement visible. Absence of disclosure is not evidence of independence.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: KKWW · 5 days ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

20. FrancescaT

NYX · 6 days ago

5Source rating / 5

Repurchases for precise application, quick drying and lasting everyday wear.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as stated
Experimental evidence weight 60/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Author explicitly describes buying or repurchasing the product; other incentives remain unknown.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: FrancescaT · 6 days ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

21. DebraS

NYX · 12 days ago

5Source rating / 5

A five-year user likes the pigment, brush tip and lasting wear.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No review-specific gift or payment statement visible. Absence of disclosure is not evidence of independence.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: DebraS · 12 days ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

22. Sol O

NYX · 22 days ago

1Source rating / 5

Her latest Dark Chocolate pen leaked onto clothing and was discarded.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No review-specific gift or payment statement visible. Absence of disclosure is not evidence of independence.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Sol O · 22 days ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

23. SalemS

NYX · a month ago

3Source rating / 5

A longtime fan likes pigment but increasingly encounters leaking pens.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No review-specific gift or payment statement visible. Absence of disclosure is not evidence of independence.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: SalemS · a month ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

24. RitaS

NYX · a month ago

5Source rating / 5

Bought more colors after enjoying vivid, smoothly applied black and brown.

Consumer reviewSelf-purchased, as stated
Experimental evidence weight 60/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 1.00. Author explicitly describes buying or repurchasing the product; other incentives remain unknown.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: RitaS · a month ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

25. SophiaR

NYX · 2 months ago

5Source rating / 5

Finds the black liner sharp and long-lasting over set makeup.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No review-specific gift or payment statement visible. Absence of disclosure is not evidence of independence.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: SophiaR · 2 months ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

26. ElizabethG

NYX · 2 months ago

3Source rating / 5

Likes precise pigment, but experiences repeated leaks and oily-lid smudging.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No review-specific gift or payment statement visible. Absence of disclosure is not evidence of independence.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: ElizabethG · 2 months ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

27. Krissy0623

NYX · 3 months ago

5Source rating / 5

Black liner stays in place through hot bakery shifts.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No review-specific gift or payment statement visible. Absence of disclosure is not evidence of independence.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: Krissy0623 · 3 months ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review

28. LizJ

NYX · 4 months ago

5Source rating / 5

Likes quick-drying black and dark brown for precise, lasting lines.

Consumer reviewCommercial relationship unknown
Experimental evidence weight 36/100
Why this weight?

Documentation quality: 60/100. Attributable firsthand use with specific performance context; identity unverified.

Commercial factor: 0.60. No review-specific gift or payment statement visible. Absence of disclosure is not evidence of independence.

Numeric stars shown immediately beside this individual review. Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

The weight combines these two factors. It is an experimental editorial judgment, not a probability that this review is true.

Source locator: LizJ · 4 months ago. Research snapshot: 2026-11-16.

Read the original review
How the score worksReview weights, filters & source mix

More detailed experience carries more weight. Known sponsorship, gifts, affiliate ties and incentives reduce it. Unknown relationships stay labeled as unknown.

Weight = documentation quality × commercial factor. These are experimental editorial choices, not a probability that a review is true.

Unknown relationships remain included. Verified purchase does not mean incentive-free.

Adjust commercial weights

Source influence

ulta.com16 reviews
57%
influenster.com7 reviews
32%
nyxcosmetics.com3 reviews
11%
Every contribution to the score
ReviewerRatingWeightContribution
Kathy1/50.180.18
Kait5/50.391.95
Stacy3/50.300.90
Anne1/50.390.39
Brit1/50.180.18
quinn1/50.390.39
Bee1/50.390.39
xc1/50.300.30
Deborah5/50.180.90
Moo3/50.300.90
Texas Girly2/50.300.60
Trina1/50.500.50
Soska1/50.300.30
Adeline2/50.651.30
LBinCLE5/50.301.50
Jaythan5/50.301.50
KKWW5/50.361.80
FrancescaT5/50.603.00
DebraS5/50.361.80
Sol O1/50.360.36
SalemS3/50.361.08
RitaS5/50.603.00
SophiaR5/50.361.80
ElizabethG3/50.361.08
Krissy06235/50.361.80
LizJ5/50.361.80

Weighted total 29.70 ÷ total weight 9.43 = 3.1 / 5

0 of 26 included scores are estimated from text. At least 10 eligible reviews are required.

A large source can dominate. This accessible-page sample is not representative of all buyers. Full methodology

Research notesIdentity, store ratings & limitations

Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen, not Epic Wear or other NYX liner lines. Black and lighter brown shades are represented; Graham Cracker is explicitly identified in one account.

Check product identity

Known repeat authors are consolidated. Identities and batches cannot always be verified across platforms. Public review ordering and source availability can bias the sample.

Selected for accessible product-specific consumer reviews, not a claim about current popularity ranking. Selection source

A SEPARATE VIEW

What do the stores show?

These are platform-wide ratings observed during research. They are not our weighted score, and the full review collections behind them have not been read.

Ulta

Platform total, separate from the individually read sample. May include syndicated or incentivized reviews and grouped shades.

4.2 / 55,229 platform ratings

AI-assisted research · Snapshot: 2026-11-16. This is a synthesis of published accounts, not our own product test. All coverage counts